Top IT Vendor Management Challenges in 2025 And How to Solve Them

Why 2025 Is a Turning Point for IT Vendor Management

If you thought managing vendors was under control, think again.

The landscape of IT vendor management is shifting fast. More vendors, rising cloud costs, tighter regulations, and vendor networks that look nothing like the simple supplier relationships of the past.

You're dealing with complexity that didn't exist five years ago.

With cloud, SaaS, and outsourcing, many companies now juggle dozens or hundreds of IT vendors. That sprawl makes governance nearly impossible.

The modern IT leader faces a tough spot: you need more vendors to stay competitive, yet each new vendor brings risk, cost, and management overhead.

In this article, I'll walk you through the top challenges facing IT vendor management in 2025—and show you exactly how to solve them.

‍

Challenge #1: Vendor Proliferation & Ecosystem Complexity

The Problem

Most companies now work with dozens or hundreds of IT vendors.

That creates chaos.

You lose visibility into who's providing what, where the dependencies are, and what you're actually paying for. Contracts duplicate, licenses overlap, and consistent governance becomes impossible.

The problem isn't just the number—it's how connected everything is. Your CRM talks to your marketing platform, which connects to your data warehouse, which feeds your analytics tools. Each vendor becomes a point in a complex web.

When one vendor changes an API or goes down, the effects ripple through your entire tech stack.

Shadow IT makes this worse. Business units sign up for SaaS tools without telling IT. You only find out when something breaks or an invoice appears.

The Impact

• Loss of control: You can't manage what you can't see.
• Higher risk: Inconsistent SLAs and security gaps multiply across vendors.
• Wasted money: Duplicate licenses and redundant services become normal.
• Integration headaches: Managing connections between vendors drains engineering time.

How to Solve It

1. Build a Complete Vendor Inventory

Start by cataloging every vendor. List what services they provide, what systems they connect to, what data they access, and who owns the relationship.

You can't manage what you don't measure.

Group vendors by how critical they are. Strategic partners who are vital to operations. Tactical vendors who are important but replaceable. Commodity vendors who are easy to switch.

2. Use a Tiering Strategy

Focus your attention on the vendors that matter most.

Your Tier 1 vendors—critical or high-risk—get quarterly reviews, constant monitoring, and executive attention. Tier 2 vendors get annual reviews and standard oversight. Tier 3 vendors can be managed through automated processes.

Not all vendors deserve the same level of attention.

3. Use a Centralized System

Pull all vendor data into one place: contracts, performance metrics, compliance docs, spending.

This creates visibility and kills the spreadsheet chaos.

A good vendor management system gives you one source of truth. It tracks contract terms, renewal dates, spending, performance, security assessments, and compliance status.

4. Consolidate Where It Makes Sense

Look for redundant vendors and overlapping services.

Do you have three vendors doing similar things? Can you get better terms by consolidating with one or two?

But be smart about it. Don't create single points of failure or vendor lock-in just to reduce your vendor count.

‍

Challenge #2: Lack of Performance Visibility & SLA Enforcement

The Problem

Many IT vendor management programs lack clear metrics, dashboards, or regular reviews.

Without those, vendors drift.

A recent survey showed 84% of organizations had disruptions because of third-party risks. When you can't measure vendor performance, you can't hold them accountable.

The issue often starts at signing. SLAs are vague or impossible to measure. "Best effort" support and "industry-standard" uptime mean nothing when you need to hold a vendor accountable.

Even with good SLAs, many organizations don't monitor them. Performance data sits in vendor portals nobody checks. By the time you realize a vendor is underperforming, you've already suffered the damage.

The Impact

• Missed SLAs: Vendors underperform without consequence.
• Unexpected outages: Problems only surface after they hurt users.
• No accountability: Vendors operate without oversight or reason to improve.
• Poor user experience: Your internal customers suffer while you stay in the dark.

How to Solve It

1. Define Clear, Measurable SLAs

Set specific targets: uptime percentages, response times, resolution rates, support quality.

Vague SLAs are worthless.

Tie SLAs to business outcomes, not just technical metrics. Instead of "99% uptime," say "service available during business hours with no more than 4 hours of total downtime per quarter."

Include financial penalties for violations. Without teeth, SLAs are just wishes.

2. Create Vendor Scorecards

Track vendor performance against your metrics in real time.

Make performance visible to both your team and the vendor.

Use a simple scoring system—red/yellow/green or numbers—that shows performance at a glance. Share these with vendors regularly. Transparency drives accountability.

3. Hold Regular Reviews

Meet with vendors monthly or quarterly. Discuss results, point out gaps, and agree on fixes.

Consistent accountability drives consistent performance.

These shouldn't be one-way reports. Use them to work on improvements, discuss upcoming needs, and align on direction.

Write down action items and track follow-through. Vendors who keep missing commitments should face escalation or contract review.

4. Automate Monitoring

Manual tracking doesn't scale. Connect vendor systems to your monitoring tools to capture performance data automatically.

Use APIs to pull service metrics and incident data into your vendor management system. Set up automated alerts when vendors fall below SLA thresholds.

‍

Challenge #3: Cost Overruns & Hidden Spend

The Problem

IT vendor management isn't just about risk and performance—it's about cost.

Many organizations struggle with hidden spend, unused licenses, contract creep, and surprise renewals. A recent survey found 94% of IT leaders struggle with cloud costs.

The shift to SaaS and usage-based pricing makes cost management much harder. Old enterprise software had predictable annual costs. Today's vendors charge by user, transaction, storage, compute—often with complex pricing that makes forecasting nearly impossible.

Usage creep is sneaky. You start with 50 licenses and grow to 200 as teams adopt the tool. But when projects end or people leave, nobody cancels those licenses. You're paying for seats that haven't been used in months.

Auto-renewals catch you off guard. That three-year contract just renewed automatically at a 20% increase. You only find out when the invoice arrives.

The Impact

• Budget shocks: Unexpected costs blow through forecasts.
• Lower ROI: You're paying for things you don't use.
• Wasted money: Unused licenses and forgotten subscriptions drain your budget.
• Weak negotiation: When you don't track spending, you can't negotiate based on actual usage.

How to Solve It

1. Audit Your Vendor Spend

Map all vendor contracts, license usage, and renewal dates.

Find out what you're actually using versus what you're paying for.

A good audit answers: Who are we paying? How much? For what? Who's using it? Are we getting value?

Look for quick wins: unused licenses to reclaim, duplicate services to consolidate, auto-renewals to renegotiate.

Do this at least once a year, and quarterly for your biggest vendors.

2. Write Better Contracts

Include clauses for cost transparency, termination rights, and usage caps.

Protect yourself from vendor pricing games.

Negotiate caps on annual price increases (like no more than 5% per year). Require 90-day notice before price changes. Include the right to reduce licenses without penalty.

Avoid auto-renewals, or make sure they require you to opt in rather than opt out.

3. Use FinOps Practices

Tie vendor spend to business outcomes. Charge costs back to the teams that use them.

When teams see the cost, they use resources more wisely.

Instead of IT absorbing all vendor costs, charge them to the business units using them. This creates natural incentives for optimization.

When marketing sees the monthly cost of their automation platform, they're more likely to cut waste.

4. Reclaim Unused Services

Find unused licenses and services. Renegotiate or cancel them.

Every unused license is wasted money.

Most SaaS platforms show usage analytics—use them. Find users who haven't logged in for 60+ days and reclaim those licenses.

For infrastructure services, compare actual use versus what you're paying for. If you're paying for capacity you don't use, downgrade.

Don't be afraid to cancel services that aren't delivering value.

‍

Challenge #4: Vendor Lock-In & Lack of Flexibility

The Problem

When you rely heavily on one vendor—especially for cloud or platforms—you get locked in.

Switching costs go up. Flexibility disappears. You lose negotiation power.

Lock-in happens slowly. You start with one service, it works well, so you expand. Before long, your data and workflows are deeply embedded in that vendor's system.

Switching becomes too expensive and disruptive. Migrating data, rewriting integrations, retraining users—it can take months or years.

Vendors know this. Once you're locked in, they have pricing power. You can't easily leave, so renewals become one-sided.

The Impact

• Weak negotiation position: You're at the vendor's mercy for pricing.
• Can't innovate: You can't pivot when the vendor can't keep up.
• Strategic risk: If they have an outage or get acquired, you're stuck.
• Competitive disadvantage: Competitors use better solutions while you're constrained.

How to Solve It

1. Plan Your Exit Before You Sign

Build data portability and migration help into every major contract.

Your contract should spell out how you get your data if you leave: in what format, at what cost, and how quickly. Require the vendor to help with migration.

Include terms that protect you if the vendor discontinues the product or gets acquired. You should be able to leave without penalty in those cases.

2. Use Multiple Vendors

Avoid putting all your eggs in one basket.

For critical capabilities, work with at least two vendors. This doesn't mean duplicating everything, but it does mean avoiding scenarios where one vendor controls an entire domain.

Use multi-cloud strategies to avoid cloud lock-in. Build applications to work across clouds where you can.

3. Require Open Standards

Demand open standards and APIs that reduce dependency.

The easier it is to leave, the better the vendor will treat you.

Choose vendors that support open standards and provide good APIs. Avoid proprietary formats that make migration hard.

Require vendors to let you export data in standard formats (CSV, JSON, XML) without fees.

4. Review Vendor Roadmaps Regularly

Check whether vendor capabilities still match your needs.

Don't stay loyal to vendors that can't evolve with you.

Hold annual strategic reviews with major vendors. Look at their product roadmap against your business strategy. Are they building what you need? Are they dropping features you rely on?

Watch for warning signs: less innovation, leadership changes, acquisition rumors, money problems.

‍

Challenge #5: Security, Compliance & Risk in Vendor Ecosystems

The Problem

Modern IT vendor management is high-stakes.

Third-party breaches, regulatory fines, and supply chain weaknesses are real threats. Regulators in 2025 are watching vendor oversight closely.

You're responsible when your vendor fails. When your vendor gets breached and your customer data leaks, regulators and customers blame you. "Our vendor got hacked" isn't a defense.

The threat landscape keeps evolving. Attackers target software supply chains. Ransomware groups exploit vendor relationships to hit multiple victims at once.

Compliance requirements keep getting tighter. GDPR, CCPA, HIPAA, SOC 2, and industry rules all require vendor oversight. You must prove that vendors handling your data meet security and privacy standards.

The Impact

• Data breaches: Vendors become your weakest security link.
• Regulatory fines: Non-compliance through vendors still costs you millions.
• Reputation damage: Vendor failures become your failures in customers' eyes.
• Business disruption: Vendor security incidents can force you to suspend services.

How to Solve It

1. Build Vendor Risk into Your Process

Check vendor security during procurement and continuously after.

Require vendors to complete security questionnaires, provide SOC 2 reports, and prove compliance with relevant standards.

Classify vendors by risk based on what data they access and how critical they are. High-risk vendors should get thorough security reviews.

2. Monitor Continuously

Don't just check security at onboarding. Keep monitoring.

Threats evolve. Your oversight must too.

Use continuous vendor risk monitoring that tracks security incidents, compliance changes, and emerging threats.

Require vendors to tell you immediately about security incidents or breaches. Define what counts as a major incident and what information they must provide.

Reassess security regularly, especially when vendors make big changes or get acquired.

3. Write Strong Contracts

Include audit rights, breach notification requirements, and exit clauses.

Your contract is your last line of defense.

Include the right to audit vendor security controls. This should extend to their subcontractors.

Require specific breach notification timelines—ideally within 24 hours. Define what information vendors must provide and what fixes they must make.

Include terms that protect you from liability when vendors fail.

4. Map Your Data Flows

Know exactly what data vendors access and how they're connected to your systems.

You can't protect what you can't see.

Create a map showing what data each vendor accesses, how they access it, where they store it, and who they share it with.

Document how vendors connect to each other. If Vendor A feeds data to Vendor B, a breach at Vendor A could cascade.

‍

Challenge #6: Internal Silos & Misalignment

The Problem

Good IT vendor management needs alignment across IT, procurement, legal, and business units.

Too often, those groups work separately. Governance suffers.

IT evaluates technical fit. Procurement focuses on price. Legal worries about liability. Business units care about features and user experience.

These different views are valuable, but when they're not aligned, vendor management gets fragmented. You end up with contracts that satisfy procurement but don't address IT's needs.

Shadow IT happens when business units bypass IT and procurement to sign up for services directly. They're frustrated by slow approvals and want to move fast. But these unauthorized vendors create blind spots.

The Impact

• Mismatched contracts: Terms don't reflect actual business or technical needs.
• Delays: Stakeholders work against each other, slowing everything down.
• Confusion: Different teams promise different things to vendors.
• Security gaps: When IT doesn't know about vendors, they can't ensure proper controls.

How to Solve It

1. Create a Vendor Management Office

Build a cross-functional team with clear authority.

Bring together people from IT, procurement, legal, security, finance, and key business units. This team owns the vendor process from selection through exit.

The VMO sets standards, approves vendors, monitors performance, and handles escalations.

The VMO needs executive support and real authority. Without it, it becomes just another meeting people ignore.

2. Align on Shared Goals

Get IT, procurement, and business units working toward the same metrics.

Instead of each group optimizing for its own goals, define shared success: total cost of ownership, business value, risk reduction, user satisfaction, strategic fit.

Create scorecards that capture multiple dimensions. This prevents optimizing cost at the expense of security or quality.

3. Standardize Your Process

Create vendor onboarding, review, and exit processes that include all stakeholders.

Document your vendor lifecycle: how vendors are found and evaluated, what approvals are needed, how contracts are negotiated, how vendors are onboarded, how performance is monitored, and how relationships end.

Build templates and checklists for consistency. Every vendor should go through the same evaluation, security review, and approval.

Make the process as smooth as possible to reduce shadow IT. If your official process takes six months, people will find workarounds.

4. Share Your Vendor Strategy

Help business units understand how vendors support business goals.

Transparency builds alignment.

Explain why certain vendors are strategic partners, what capabilities they provide, and how business units should work with them.

Create a vendor catalog that business units can check when they need capabilities. If someone needs a collaboration tool, they can see what's already approved.

Teach business units about the risks of shadow IT and the benefits of proper channels: better pricing, stronger security, faster support.

‍

Challenge #7: Rapid Technology Change & Vendor Innovation Lag

The Problem

Technology evolves fast—AI, cloud, edge, IoT.

Vendors may not keep up. You risk buying solutions that become outdated.

The pace of change creates a tough problem. You need vendors who can support your needs for 3-5 years, but predicting what you'll need that far out is nearly impossible.

Established vendors often struggle to innovate. They're improving existing products for existing customers rather than building breakthrough capabilities.

Meanwhile, startups offer cutting-edge features but carry higher risk. They may lack enterprise security, scale, or staying power. Betting on the wrong startup can leave you stranded.

The Impact

• Missed opportunities: You can't use new capabilities because your vendors don't offer them.
• Misaligned solutions: Vendor offerings don't fit your future needs.
• Technical debt: Legacy vendor platforms hold you back.
• Competitive disadvantage: Competitors adopt new tech while you're stuck.

How to Solve It

1. Evaluate Innovation During Selection

Look at vendors' roadmaps and R&D investment, not just current features.

Ask about their innovation strategy. How much do they invest in R&D? How do they develop new capabilities? What's their track record?

Look for vendors who engage with emerging tech. Do they have AI research teams? Are they investing in edge computing?

Choose vendors with open architectures that let you add new capabilities even if the vendor doesn't provide them.

2. Review Vendor Roadmaps Regularly

Check how vendor plans align with your future needs.

Hold annual strategic reviews with major vendors. Share your business strategy and tech direction. Ask vendors to map their roadmap against your needs.

Find gaps where vendor plans don't match yours. These gaps are risks—you'll need alternative solutions or you'll need to influence vendor priorities.

Use these sessions to ask for capabilities you need. Vendors often adjust roadmaps based on customer input.

3. Test New Capabilities

Include contract terms that let you pilot new vendor features at reduced cost or risk.

This lets you evaluate innovations before committing fully.

Create an innovation budget for testing emerging tech and vendors. This should be separate from operational spending and focused on learning.

Run structured pilots with clear success criteria and timelines. Don't let pilots drag on without decisions.

4. Keep Budget Flexible

Reserve part of your vendor budget for new tech or vendors.

Flexibility requires financial room.

If 100% of your budget is locked into existing contracts, you can't adopt new solutions when opportunities arise.

Reserve 10-15% of your budget for new initiatives. This creates space to bring on new vendors or pilot emerging tech.

‍

A Practical Framework for Tackling These Challenges

To turn these insights into action, use this four-step framework:

1. Assess

Map your current vendor ecosystem—vendors, contracts, spend, risk, performance.

You can't improve what you don't understand.

Start with a complete vendor inventory. Document every relationship, including shadow IT found through expense reports.

Check current performance: Are vendors meeting SLAs? Are costs under control? Are security requirements met? Where are the biggest gaps?

2. Prioritize

Find which challenges matter most in your situation.

Focus on the highest-impact issues first.

Not every organization faces the same vendor challenges. A fast-growing startup might struggle most with vendor sprawl, while a regulated company might prioritize security.

Figure out which challenges create the most risk, cost, or friction. Start there.

Look for quick wins alongside longer-term projects. Reclaiming unused licenses might take weeks, while building a VMO might take months.

3. Implement

Launch targeted initiatives for each challenge:

• Vendor consolidation
• Performance scorecards
• Cost governance
• Risk monitoring

Create project plans with clear owners, timelines, and success metrics.

Start with pilots for major changes. Test new processes with a few vendors before rolling out everywhere.

Communicate changes to stakeholders. Explain why you're implementing new practices and how they'll help.

4. Monitor & Refine

Review outcomes regularly and adjust your approach.

Vendor management is never "done."

Set up regular governance reviews—monthly or quarterly—to check how your initiatives are performing.

Track results: Are vendor counts stabilizing? Is spend under control? Are security incidents decreasing?

Be willing to adjust based on what you learn. If something isn't working, figure out why and fix it.

‍

‍

Create a Vendor Health Dashboard

Build a dashboard with key indicators:

• Vendor count (total and by tier)
• Spend per vendor and total spend
• Risk rating distribution
• SLA performance rates
• Innovation and roadmap alignment scores

Use it to drive executive visibility and governance.

Make vendor performance impossible to ignore.

Your dashboard should give executives summary views and give managers detailed drill-downs. Update it at least monthly.

Use the dashboard in governance meetings to drive decisions. When considering new vendors, reference existing performance to set expectations.

‍

Closing thoughts

2025 is a pivotal year for IT vendor management.

The challenges you face—vendor sprawl, cost overruns, lock-in, risk, internal misalignment—are real. But they're not impossible to solve.

With clear metrics, strong governance, cross-functional alignment, and willingness to evolve, you can turn these challenges into advantages.

Organizations that master vendor management in 2025 won't just reduce risk and control costs—they'll unlock innovation, improve flexibility, and deliver better outcomes.

If you're ready to move from reactive vendor management to strategic leadership, take one step today: pick the most urgent challenge and build a focused plan around it.

The complexity won't disappear. But with the right approach, you can master it.

Your vendors should enable your success, not limit it. Make 2025 the year you take control.